ArcaneMetriX
Spooky Season

The Spookiest Cards in Magic

Six cards that should not be looked at after dark, picked for their art, their names and what they do to you, with a place to add your own submission. Published: October 1, 2026.

Some cards are just downright creepy

Magic has always kept one foot in the horror aisle. Innistrad gave us werewolves and folk tales, Phyrexia gave us compleation, the Eldrazi gave us creepy tentacle monsters. These six are the ones we keep turning face down on the table. Read through them, then tell us which one you would least like to meet, or write in another card that haunts you most.

Which one is the spookiest?

Six of our picks, and room for yours. The vote is for the artwork: use the arrows on a picture to flip through printings of a card; each one counts as its own submission. Once you have picked, the results appear and you can see how everyone else feels. Every picture opens the card in ArcaneMetriX to explore in more detail.

Loading the poll…

Our six

  1. The Meathook Massacre
    INR #122 · Chris Seaman

    The Meathook Massacre

    Art by Chris Seaman

    Dozens of hooks overhead on a legendary enchantment that benefits you for every death at the table. The name does most of the heavy lifting... Or chopping.

  2. Old Stickfingers
    DSC #227 · Jehan Choo

    Old Stickfingers

    Art by Jehan Choo

    A thing made of twigs and joints that should not bend that way peering at you from the tall grass. Innistrad folk horror at its finest: no monster movie, just a story the village tells.

  3. Emrakul, the Promised End
    INR #5 · Jaime Jones

    Emrakul, the Promised End

    Art by Jaime Jones

    The sky itself comes apart revealing an interdimensional presence with powers beyond comprehension. Emrakul invades your consciousness and overtakes your being, twisting and corrupting your very essence.

  4. Sheoldred, the Apocalypse
    DMU #107 · Chris Rahn

    Sheoldred, the Apocalypse

    Art by Chris Rahn

    A praetor emerging from a monstrous, multi-jointed body covered in corroded metal plates, and moving with spider-like agility. Known for her cunning, covert tactics, and misinformation, embodying acquisition of power by any means necessary.

  5. Grist, the Hunger Tide
    DSC #220 · Yongjae Choi

    Grist, the Hunger Tide

    Art by Yongjae Choi

    A swarm of insects wearing the shape of a planeswalker. Look closely and it stops being one thing, which is so, so much worse.

  6. Thing in the Ice
    INR #91 · Svetlin Velinov

    Thing in the Ice

    Art by Svetlin Velinov

    Something under the ice is waiting. Four spells later the seal of the ice is broken, the thing is now lurking below the surface... Watching. Waiting. Flip it if you dare.

Or write one in

Nothing here unsettles you like a card you know? Name it, pick its artwork, and it counts in the same pool. The three artworks readers have voted for most are added to the pool for voting.

Build something wicked

Every card above has a home in Commander. Click any picture to open it in the web app and see what it pairs with.