The Spookiest Cards in Magic
Some cards are just downright creepy
Magic has always kept one foot in the horror aisle. Innistrad gave us werewolves and folk tales, Phyrexia gave us compleation, the Eldrazi gave us creepy tentacle monsters. These six are the ones we keep turning face down on the table. Read through them, then tell us which one you would least like to meet, or write in another card that haunts you most.
Which one is the spookiest?
Six of our picks, and room for yours. The vote is for the artwork: use the arrows on a picture to flip through printings of a card; each one counts as its own submission. Once you have picked, the results appear and you can see how everyone else feels. Every picture opens the card in ArcaneMetriX to explore in more detail.
Loading the poll…
Our six
Or write one in
Nothing here unsettles you like a card you know? Name it, pick its artwork, and it counts in the same pool. The three artworks readers have voted for most are added to the pool for voting.
Build something wicked
Every card above has a home in Commander. Click any picture to open it in the web app and see what it pairs with.





