Why Layers Exist
Most of the time, effects on a creature just add up. Grizzly Bears with Giant Growth is a 5/5, and nobody needs a rule for that. The trouble starts when effects disagree. Turn to Frog says a creature "becomes a blue Frog with base power and toughness 1/1." Giant Growth says it gets +3/+3. If the Bears got Giant Growth first and then Turn to Frog, is it a 1/1, because the Frog came last? Or a 4/4?
If the answer depended on which spell happened to resolve last, the same two cards would do different things on different turns, and players would argue about it. So the rules sort every effect that changes a permanent into layers, and apply the layers in order, from 1 to 7. In this case, setting power and toughness comes before adding to them, every time. The Bears are a 4/4, whichever spell came first.
Layers are about effects that last a while: "until end of turn" spells, static abilities like Glorious Anthem, and counters. One-time events, like damage, aren't part of them.
The Seven Layers
Each layer handles one kind of change. The game starts from the card as printed and works down the list:
- Copy effects. Something that becomes a copy of another card takes on that card's characteristics first, before anything else is applied.
- Control. Effects that change who controls the permanent, like Mind Control.
- Text. The rare effects that change words in a card's rules text.
- Type. Effects that change card types and subtypes, such as Turn to Frog making a creature a Frog.
- Color. Effects that change color, such as Turn to Frog making it blue.
- Abilities. Effects that add or remove abilities: Jump giving flying, or Turn to Frog taking every ability away.
- Power and toughness. Everything that changes the numbers, in four sublayers of its own.
Notice that one card can act in several layers. Turn to Frog changes the creature's type in layer 4, its color in layer 5, its abilities in layer 6 and its power and toughness in layer 7. Each part waits for its own layer.
Layer 7, Up Close
Power and toughness changes are the ones that come up in nearly every game, so layer 7 is split in four:
- 7a: abilities that define power and toughness. Tarmogoyf's power "is equal to the number of card types among cards in all graveyards." Abilities like this work out the base numbers first.
- 7b: effects that set power and toughness to a number. Turn to Frog's "base power and toughness 1/1" lives here.
- 7c: effects and counters that add or subtract. Giant Growth's +3/+3, Glorious Anthem's +1/+1, Disfigure's -2/-2, and every +1/+1 or -1/-1 counter. They all simply add up.
- 7d: effects that switch power and toughness. Twisted Image swaps the two numbers, after everything else.
The key fact is that 7b comes before 7c. Setting a creature to 1/1 doesn't erase its counters or its pump spells. They're applied afterward, on top of the new base. That's why the Bears in the first section are a 4/4: 1/1 from Turn to Frog in 7b, then +3/+3 from Giant Growth in 7c.
Good to know: counters sit in layer 7c, right beside "+N/+N" effects. Older explanations sometimes give counters a sublayer of their own. Under current rules they share 7c, and since everything in 7c adds up, the result is the same either way.
Apply the Layers
Here is a Serra Angel, a 4/4 white Angel with flying and vigilance, with four effects on it to start. Turn effects on and off, and move them earlier or later to change their timestamps. Watch which changes depend on order and which never do.
With the first three on, the Angel is a 5/5 blue Frog with no abilities: base 1/1 from Turn to Frog, then +1/+1 from the counter and +3/+3 from Giant Growth. Move Giant Growth after Turn to Frog and nothing changes, because 7b always comes before 7c. Turn on Glorious Anthem and it's a 6/6: the Frog lost its own abilities, but the Anthem's +1/+1 comes from the Anthem.
Timestamps Break Ties
Layers decide the order between different kinds of effect. Within a single layer, the order is the timestamp: when each effect began. A spell's effect gets its timestamp when the spell resolves. A static ability's effect gets the timestamp of its permanent, from when that permanent entered the battlefield. Older effects apply first.
In layer 7c, timestamps never change anything, because adding numbers gives the same total in any order. Where they matter is in layers where effects overwrite each other. Turn on Jump in the widget above. Jump gives flying and Turn to Frog removes all abilities, both in layer 6:
- Jump, then Turn to Frog: flying is added, then every ability is removed. The Frog can't fly.
- Turn to Frog, then Jump: every ability is removed, then flying is added. The Frog flies.
So if your opponent casts Turn to Frog on your flier, casting Jump afterward gives the flying back. Casting it before does nothing for you.
One last rule exists for unusual boards. Sometimes one effect changes whether another applies at all, or what it applies to, within the same layer. Then the rules apply the one it depends on first, whatever the timestamps say. This is called dependency. It's rare in everyday games, and when it comes up, a judge or the card's rulings will settle it.
Puzzle: What Size Is It?
Your Grizzly Bears has a +1/+1 counter, and you control Glorious Anthem. You pump the Bears with Giant Growth, and your opponent answers with Turn to Frog. Work out its size, layer by layer.
The answer, in words: after Turn to Frog, the Bears are a 6/6. Turn to Frog sets the base to 1/1 in layer 7b, and then layer 7c adds the +1/+1 counter, Glorious Anthem's +1/+1 and Giant Growth's +3/+3. Losing all abilities doesn't stop the Anthem, whose ability is on the Anthem. At cleanup both spells end, and the Bears are a 4/4: the printed 2/2 plus the counter and the Anthem.
Questions Players Ask
What are layers in MTG?
Layers are the order the rules use to apply effects that change a permanent. Copy effects come first, then control, text, type, color and abilities, and power and toughness last, in layer 7. Within a layer, effects apply in timestamp order.
In what order are power and toughness changes applied?
Layer 7 has four sublayers: 7a for abilities that define power and toughness, 7b for effects that set them to a number, 7c for effects and counters that add or subtract, and 7d for effects that switch power and toughness.
Do +1/+1 counters still count after a creature's power and toughness are set?
Yes. Setting power and toughness happens in layer 7b, and counters apply in layer 7c, which comes after. A creature with a +1/+1 counter that becomes a 1/1 is a 2/2.
What is a timestamp in Magic?
A timestamp is when an effect began: when a spell resolved, or when a permanent with a static ability entered the battlefield. When two effects apply in the same layer, the older one applies first.