ArcaneMetriX
Learn to Play: Unit 4, Lesson 3

Mulligans: When to Keep a Hand

Don't like your opening hand? Shuffle it away and draw seven new cards, then put one on the bottom for each time you did. Keep hands with two to five lands and something to cast.

A 7 minute lesson with hands to keep or send back. Last reviewed: November 18, 2026.

Your Opening Hand

Every game starts the same way: each player shuffles their deck and draws seven cards. Those seven are your opening hand, and they decide a lot. A hand with no lands can't cast anything. A hand of nothing but lands has nothing to cast. Either can lose a game before it has started.

So Magic lets you send a hand back. That's a mulligan: you shuffle your hand away and draw a new one, at the cost of a card. Before the first turn, each player, starting with the one who goes first, looks at their hand and decides to keep it or take a mulligan.

The London Mulligan

The rule Magic uses today is called the London mulligan. It works like this:

  1. Shuffle your hand back into your library.
  2. Draw a new hand of seven cards.
  3. Decide again: keep it, or mulligan again.
  4. When you keep, put one card from your hand on the bottom of your library for each mulligan you took, in any order you like.

So you always see seven cards, and you choose which to give up. After one mulligan you keep six of seven; after two, five of seven. Choosing what to put back is a real advantage: you can send away the card your hand is least likely to use, like a six-mana creature in a hand with two lands.

A hand of six lands goes back into the library, a new seven is drawn, and after keeping it one extra Mountain goes to the bottom of the library, leaving six cards.

You can keep taking mulligans as long as you have cards to keep, but each one costs a card, and a card is a lot. Most players will mulligan to six without much thought, think hard before going to five, and keep almost any five.

Good to know: in a multiplayer game, such as a four-player Commander game, your first mulligan is free. You shuffle and draw a new seven, and keep all seven. Mulligans after that cost a card each, as usual. Commander for Beginners has the rest of that format's rules.

In a four-player Commander game, a hand with no lands goes back into the library and a new seven is drawn. The first mulligan is free, so all seven are kept.

What a Keepable Hand Looks Like

A good opening hand does two things: it has the lands to cast its spells, and it has spells to cast. For a 60-card deck with about 24 lands, the rough guide is:

Zero or one land: mulligan, almost always. You need to draw a land every turn just to keep going, and a missed land drop on turn two can be the whole game. Two lands: keep it if the hand has cheap spells that those lands can pay for. Three or four lands: the best hands, as long as there are spells too. Five lands: keep it if the two spells are good ones. Six or seven lands: mulligan; you'll draw more lands anyway.

Then look past the land count. Do the lands make the colors your spells need? A hand with two Forests and three red spells has two lands that can't cast anything in it. Can you do something on your second or third turn? A hand with three lands and four cards that cost six won't, even if the numbers look right. A useful test is to say your first three turns out loud: "Forest, Llanowar Elves; Mountain, Grizzly Bears; Forest, Hill Giant." If you can, keep.

A hand of three lands, Llanowar Elves, Grizzly Bears, Hill Giant and Lightning Bolt plays out its first three turns: Forest and Llanowar Elves, Mountain and Grizzly Bears, Forest and Hill Giant.

Deal some hands from a red-green deck of 24 lands and 36 spells, and decide for yourself. If you take a mulligan, you'll choose which cards to put on the bottom when you keep.

A hand dealer: it deals seven cards from a red-green deck of 12 Forests, 12 Mountains and 36 creatures and spells. You keep or mulligan, and after a mulligan you choose which cards go to the bottom.

The Old Rule, and the Scry That Went With It

You may hear older players mention a scry after a mulligan. From 2015 to 2019, Magic used the Vancouver mulligan: each new hand had one card fewer than the last, drawn rather than chosen, and a player who kept a hand of fewer than seven cards could scry 1, looking at the top card of their library and choosing to leave it there or put it on the bottom.

The London mulligan replaced it in 2019, and it has no scry. Today you draw seven every time and put cards on the bottom, and that's all. If a friend tells you to scry after a mulligan, they learned the old rule.

Puzzle: Keep, Mulligan, Bottom

A two-player game, with the red-green deck from above. Look at your opening hand, decide, and if you mulligan, choose what to put back.

A puzzle board: mulligan a one-land hand, keep a new seven with three lands, Llanowar Elves, Grizzly Bears, Lightning Bolt and Colossal Dreadmaw, and put the Dreadmaw on the bottom. The answer is below the board.

The answer, in words: mulligan the first hand, because one land can't cast a hand built around three- to six-mana creatures. Keep the second, which has three lands in both colors and plays for turns one and two. Then, because you took one mulligan, put one card on the bottom: Colossal Dreadmaw, the card you'd wait longest to cast.

Questions New Players Ask

How does the mulligan work in Magic: The Gathering?

Magic uses the London mulligan. If you don't like your opening hand, shuffle it into your library and draw a new hand of seven. When you decide to keep a hand, put one card from it on the bottom of your library for each mulligan you took.

Do you scry after a mulligan?

No. The older Vancouver mulligan gave a scry to a player who kept fewer than seven cards, but the London mulligan, which replaced it in 2019, has no scry.

Is the first mulligan free in Commander?

Yes, in a multiplayer game, which is how Commander is usually played: your first mulligan is free, so you draw a new seven and keep all of them. Each mulligan after that costs one card as usual. In a one-on-one game the first mulligan costs a card like any other.

Take It Further