Tokens: Permanents Without a Card
Some cards put things onto the battlefield that were never in your deck. Raise the Alarm, for {1}{W}, creates two 1/1 white Soldier creatures. These are tokens: permanents made by an effect instead of played from your hand.
On the battlefield, a token is a permanent like any other. A Soldier token is a creature, so it can attack and block, it can be destroyed, it counts for "creatures you control," and it has summoning sickness the turn it arrives, just as a creature card would. The card that made it tells you its name, color, type and power and toughness. At a real table, players mark tokens with printed token cards, dice, or anything else that is clear to everyone.
The difference shows when a token leaves the battlefield. A token is not a card, so it can't sit in your hand, your library or your graveyard. When a token leaves the battlefield, it ceases to exist. A token that dies does go to the graveyard for an instant, long enough for abilities that care about a creature dying to notice, and then it's gone for good. A token returned to your hand vanishes the same way. Nothing can bring it back.
Tokens You'll See Often
Creature tokens like Soldiers, Zombies and Spirits are the most common, but a few artifact tokens show up so often that the rules give them a standard text. Their abilities are activated: you pay the cost, and sacrificing the token is part of it.
- Treasure: {T}, sacrifice it: add one mana of any color. A one-time mana boost.
- Food: {2}, {T}, sacrifice it: you gain 3 life.
- Clue: {2}, sacrifice it: draw a card.
Thraben Inspector makes a Clue when it enters, so it is a small creature now and a card later. Bake into a Pie destroys a creature and leaves you a Food. These artifact tokens aren't creatures, so summoning sickness doesn't apply to them: a Treasure or Food can be tapped the turn you get it.
Token Copies
Some effects create a token that is a copy of something. Cackling Counterpart creates a token copy of a creature you control. The copy has the original's printed name, cost, text, power and toughness, but not anything that happened to the original: no counters, no damage, and it isn't tapped just because the original is. It enters as a new creature, so any "when this enters" ability the original has triggers again. And it is still a token: if it leaves the battlefield, it ceases to exist.
Counters Change a Permanent
A counter is a marker placed on a permanent (or, for a few kinds, on a player) to track a change that lasts. The most common is the +1/+1 counter: each one adds 1 to a creature's power and 1 to its toughness.
Compare Battlegrowth, which puts a +1/+1 counter on a creature, with Giant Growth, which gives +3/+3 "until end of turn." Giant Growth is bigger, but it wears off in the cleanup step. A counter stays for as long as the creature stays on the battlefield. Ajani's Pridemate collects a counter every time you gain life, and keeps every one.
When +1/+1 Meets -1/-1
-1/-1 counters work the other way, making a creature smaller. A creature can't keep both kinds. If it has +1/+1 counters and -1/-1 counters at the same time, the game removes them in pairs, one of each, until only one kind is left. A creature with two +1/+1 counters that gets one -1/-1 counter ends up with a single +1/+1 counter. This happens automatically as a state-based action: no one chooses it, and it doesn't use the stack.
Other Counters
A planeswalker enters with a number of loyalty counters equal to the number printed in its corner, its loyalty. Its abilities add or remove loyalty counters as their cost, and damage dealt to it removes them. A planeswalker with no loyalty counters goes to the graveyard.
Poison counters go on players, not permanents. A few cards give them out instead of dealing damage, and a player with ten or more poison counters loses the game, no matter how much life they have.
Whatever the kind, counters on a permanent are tied to it being on the battlefield. When the permanent leaves, its counters are gone. If the card ever comes back, it comes back with none of its old ones.
Tokens Come and Go
Here is a turn with tokens and a counter. You'll make two Soldiers, put a +1/+1 counter on one of them, and then see what happens when your opponent's Prodigal Pyromancer, which can tap to deal 1 damage to any target, picks one off.
Puzzle: Bake, Eat, Attack
Your opponent is at 3 life with Grizzly Bears ready to block. You have Ajani's Pridemate (a 2/2 that gets a +1/+1 counter whenever you gain life), four lands, Sol Ring (an artifact that taps for two colorless mana) and Bake into a Pie in your hand. Deal 3 damage to your opponent this turn.
The answer, in words: cast Bake into a Pie on Grizzly Bears, which destroys your opponent's only blocker and gives you a Food token. Pay {2} with Sol Ring, tap and sacrifice the Food to gain 3 life, and Ajani's Pridemate gets a +1/+1 counter, becoming a 3/3. Attack for exactly 3. You can eat the Food before attacking or after no blockers are declared; either way works.
Questions New Players Ask
What is a token in MTG?
A token is a permanent created by a card's effect rather than played from your deck. It works like any other permanent while it is on the battlefield, but when it leaves the battlefield it ceases to exist.
What happens when a creature has a +1/+1 counter and a -1/-1 counter?
They cancel out. As a state-based action, the game removes one +1/+1 counter and one -1/-1 counter at a time until the permanent has only one kind left.
Do counters stay on a creature if it leaves the battlefield?
No. When a permanent leaves the battlefield, all its counters are gone. If the card comes back, it returns as a new object with none of its old counters.
Do tokens have summoning sickness?
Yes. A creature token can't attack or use abilities with the tap symbol in their cost until you have controlled it since the start of your turn. It can block right away.