What Responding Means
When your opponent casts a spell, it doesn't happen right away. It waits on the stack, and before it resolves you get priority, a chance to act. If you cast an instant or activate an ability now, you respond to their spell. Your response goes on top of theirs, so it resolves first.
That changes the world their spell lands in. A pump spell makes your creature too big to die. A removal spell takes away the creature their aura was aimed at. A bounce spell like Unsummon returns your creature to your hand, so their removal finds nothing. Or you can stop their spell outright, with a counterspell.
Anything that can be cast or activated while something else is on the stack can be a response: instants, cards with flash, and activated abilities. Sorceries and ordinary creatures can't, since they need an empty stack.
Counterspells
A counterspell is a spell that stops another spell. To counter a spell is to take it off the stack before it resolves: it does nothing at all and goes to its owner's graveyard. The mana spent on it is gone too. Blue owns this trick, and three classic counterspells show how they differ:
- Counterspell ({U}{U}): "Counter target spell." Any spell at all, for two blue mana.
- Cancel ({1}{U}{U}): the same, for one more mana.
- Negate ({1}{U}): "Counter target noncreature spell." Cheaper, but it can't touch a creature spell.
A counterspell can only answer a spell, which leaves out three things. A land is never cast, so it can't be countered. A creature that's already on the battlefield is no longer a spell, so it's too late to counter it. And abilities on the stack aren't spells either, so "counter target spell" can't hit them.
Responding to Abilities and Triggers
Abilities use the stack just like spells, so you can respond to them too. Flametongue Kavu has a triggered ability: "When this creature enters, it deals 4 damage to target creature." That trigger goes on the stack after the Kavu arrives, and you get priority before it resolves.
Say it targets your Grizzly Bears. Giant Growth in response makes the Bears a 5/5, and the 4 damage isn't enough. Unsummon in response saves the Bears too: the trigger finds its target gone and does nothing.
What doesn't work is attacking the source. Once the trigger is on the stack, it's independent of the card that made it. Killing the Kavu in response still lets the 4 damage happen. And Counterspell can't counter the trigger, because it isn't a spell. Your chance to stop the Kavu with Counterspell was earlier, while the Kavu itself was on the stack as a creature spell. Counter it then, and it never enters, so it never triggers.
Chains of Responses
A response can be answered too. Players can keep adding to the stack for as long as they have spells and mana, each new item landing on top. When everyone finally passes, the items resolve one at a time from the top down, with a fresh round of priority after each one. A long chain is often called a counter war.
Below, your opponent casts Murder on your Serra Angel. You answer, they answer back, and you get the last word. Watch the order things resolve in, and why Murder ends up doing nothing.
Holding Priority
After you cast a spell, the rules give priority back to you. You may cast a second spell before your opponent gets a chance to answer the first. This is called holding priority. It matters when you want two things on the stack together, for example two burn spells aimed at the same creature, so your opponent can't answer the first one before the second arrives.
That's the rule. In practice, by a convention most tables share (and tournament rules write down), casting a spell is taken to mean you pass priority afterward. If you want to hold it, say so as you cast: "I'll hold priority." In casual games it rarely comes up, but it's good to know the words.
End-of-Turn Plays and Open Mana
Instants let you wait. If you leave mana untapped during your opponent's turn, you can answer whatever they do: counter their best spell, destroy an attacker, save a creature. If they do nothing worth answering, you don't lose that mana. You cast your instant during their end step instead, maybe a card that draws you cards, and your lands untap at the start of your turn moments later. Players call this "end of turn" or "end step" play.
Open mana is also information, or misinformation. Two untapped Islands tell your opponent you might hold Counterspell. Maybe you do. Maybe you're holding nothing, and the threat alone makes them play around a card you don't have, casting a weaker spell first as bait or waiting a turn. That's bluffing, and it's a fair part of the game.
Good to know: the best moment to respond is usually the last one. Waiting until a spell is actually cast, or an attacker is actually declared, means you answer the real threat instead of guessing.
Puzzle: Save the Bears
Your opponent casts Doom Blade, "Destroy target nonblack creature," on your Grizzly Bears. You have an Island and a Forest untapped, and three instants in hand. Only one of them saves the Bears.
The answer, in words: cast Negate in response, paying {1}{U} with the Island and the Forest. Doom Blade is an instant, so Negate can counter it. Giant Growth doesn't help against a destroy effect, and Cancel would work but needs two blue mana among three, which you don't have.
Questions Players Ask
What does it mean to respond to a spell in MTG?
Responding means casting an instant or activating an ability while another spell or ability is still on the stack. Yours goes on top, so it resolves first, before the thing you responded to.
Can you counter a land?
No. Playing a land doesn't use the stack, so there is nothing to counter. Counterspells target spells, and a land is never cast.
Can a counterspell stop a triggered ability?
Not one that says 'counter target spell', like Counterspell or Negate. A triggered or activated ability on the stack is not a spell. A few cards can counter abilities, and they say so.
Why do players cast instants at the end of the opponent's turn?
Mana left open during your opponent's turn can answer whatever they do. If they do nothing worth answering, you cast your instant in their end step instead, so the mana isn't wasted, and you untap at the start of your own turn right after.