Rules Nobody Has to Choose
Most things in Magic happen because someone did something: cast a spell, attacked, activated an ability. A few rules work differently. They watch the game and step in on their own whenever a certain situation exists. A creature with damage equal to its toughness is destroyed. A player at 0 life loses. These are state-based actions: actions the game takes because of the state it's in.
The game checks them whenever a player would get priority. That's after every spell or ability resolves, after combat damage, at the start of most steps, constantly. They're never checked in the middle of a spell resolving, so a creature dealt lethal damage partway through a spell stays on the battlefield until that spell has finished, then goes at the check right after.
And they don't use the stack. The check happens before anyone gets priority, so there's no moment to respond. If your creature has lethal damage, it's gone before you could cast Giant Growth on it. You had to cast Giant Growth earlier, while the damage was still on its way.
The Common Ones
There are more than a dozen state-based actions in the rules. These are the ones that come up in real games:
- A player with 0 or less life loses the game.
- A player who tried to draw from an empty library loses, at the next check after the draw, not in the middle of it.
- A player with 10 or more poison counters loses.
- A creature with 0 or less toughness goes to its owner's graveyard. It isn't destroyed, just put there, so indestructible doesn't save it.
- A creature with lethal damage is destroyed. Lethal damage means damage marked on it at least equal to its toughness.
- A creature dealt damage by a source with deathtouch is destroyed, even if that was only 1 damage.
- A planeswalker with 0 loyalty goes to its owner's graveyard.
- The legend rule. If you control two or more legendary permanents with the same name, you choose one to keep, and the rest go to their owners' graveyards.
- +1/+1 and -1/-1 counters cancel out. If a permanent has both, pairs of them are removed until only one kind is left.
- An Aura that is attached to nothing, or to something it can't legally enchant, goes to its owner's graveyard.
- A token that has left the battlefield ceases to exist. It does reach the graveyard for a moment, long enough for "dies" abilities to see it, then it's gone.
Typhoid Rats shows deathtouch: any damage it deals to a creature is enough. Darksteel Myr is a 0/1 with indestructible: damage and "destroy" can't remove it, but anything that brings its toughness to 0 can. Isamaru, Hound of Konda is legendary, so if you cast a second copy while the first is out, you keep one and the other goes to the graveyard.
All at the Same Time
When the game checks, it finds every state-based action that applies and performs them all simultaneously. Two creatures that dealt each other lethal damage die together, so neither "survives long enough" to do anything. If both players reach 0 life at once, both lose, and the game is a draw.
Then it checks again, in case the first round created a new situation. Only when nothing applies does a player get priority. Any abilities that triggered along the way, like "whenever a creature dies", go on the stack then.
Damage and Toughness Add Up
Damage doesn't go away when the spell that dealt it is done. It stays marked on a creature until the cleanup step at the end of the turn. So damage from different sources adds up: a 4/4 that took 3 damage blocking earlier in the turn dies to one more point of damage later the same turn.
Shrinking a creature works with damage too. Disfigure gives a creature -2/-2 until end of turn. Cast it on a 4/4 with 3 damage marked, and it becomes a 2/2 with 3 damage: lethal damage, so it's destroyed at the next check. Cast it on Darksteel Myr, and the Myr becomes -2/-1. It isn't destroyed (it's indestructible), but its toughness is below 1, so it goes to the graveyard anyway.
Counters follow the same rule as effects. A creature with two +1/+1 counters that gets a -1/-1 counter ends up with one +1/+1 counter after the next check: one of each is removed. Nothing about the creature's size changes, because +1/+1 and -1/-1 cancel either way. It just keeps the board tidy.
Good to know: indestructible stops "destroy", including destruction from lethal damage and deathtouch. It does not stop 0 toughness, sacrifice, exile, or returning to hand.
Puzzle: Two Blockers, Two Spells
Earlier this turn, your opponent's Serra Angel blocked your Hill Giant. The Giant died, and the Angel still has 3 damage marked on it. It's your second main phase. You have Disfigure and Shock in hand, a Swamp and a Mountain untapped, and your opponent also has Darksteel Myr. Clear both creatures away before your next attack.
The answer, in words: Disfigure goes on Darksteel Myr and Shock goes on Serra Angel, in either order. The Myr becomes -2/-1 and goes to the graveyard for having 0 or less toughness, which indestructible doesn't prevent. The Angel's 3 damage from combat is still marked, so Shock's 2 more makes 5, lethal for a 4/4. Disfigure on the Angel would also kill it, but then Shock can't touch the indestructible Myr.
Questions Players Ask
What are state-based actions in MTG?
State-based actions are rules the game checks on its own, such as a creature with lethal damage being destroyed or a player at 0 life losing. They are checked whenever a player would get priority, they all happen at once, and they never use the stack.
Can you respond to a state-based action?
No. State-based actions don't use the stack, and they are checked before anyone gets priority. By the time you could cast a spell, the creature with lethal damage is already gone.
Does indestructible stop a creature with 0 toughness from dying?
No. Indestructible stops a creature from being destroyed, but a creature with 0 or less toughness isn't destroyed. It is simply put into its owner's graveyard, so it goes even if it's indestructible.
When do you lose for drawing from an empty library?
Not on the spot. The next time state-based actions are checked, any player who tried to draw from an empty library since the last check loses the game.